Comparative Quality of Service Analysis of VPN Protocols on IPv6

Sabela Trisiana Oktavia; Dimas Febriyan Priambodo; Nanang Trianto; Rahmat  Purwoko

doi:10.23887/janapati.v12i3.69264

Authors

Sabela Trisiana Oktavia National Cyber and Crypto Polytechnic
Dimas Febriyan Priambodo National Cyber and Crypto Polytechnic
Nanang Trianto National Cyber and Crypto Polytechnic
Rahmat Purwoko National Cyber and Crypto Polytechnic

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.23887/janapati.v12i3.69264

Keywords:

IPv6, Quality of Service, VPN

Abstract

The increase in internet users has led to the depletion of IPv4 supplies and the increase in cyber attacks, one of which is data leakage incidents. Several innovations were created such as switching to IPv6 which provides more addresses and implementing VPN technology to secure internet communications. The solution using VPN is believed to secure the network from various types of attacks from outside the network by creating a tunnel with a certain encryption algorithm as a data exchange path. Some studies reveal that using VPN can cause delay which will affect QoS performance. Therefore, this research will be conducted to provide evidence as well as a comparison between the WireGuard and L2TP / IPSec VPN protocols on IPv6 based on Quality of Service parameters which include delay, jitter, packet loss, throughput, and MOS with three tests namely iPerf3, FTP, and remote desktop . The measurement is done by making a sample model with mikrotik and 6to4 tunnel. From the series of tests, it is known that the L2TP/IPSec protocol is better than the WireGuard protocol judging by the performance generated in tests with FTP and remote desktop. This discovery can be used by end users or other researchers to use VPN more objectively based on the technology.

References

G. K. Ordabayeva, M. Othman, B. Kirgizbayeva, Z. D. Iztaev, and A. Bayegizova, “A systematic review of transition from IPV4 to IPV6,” in ACM International Conference Proceeding Series, 2020. doi: 10.1145/3410352.3410735.

APJII, “Laporan Survei Internet Indonesia APJII 2021-2022,” 2022.

“Digital 2022: Another Year of Bumper Growth - We Are Social,” 2022. [Online]. Available: https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2022/01/digital-2022-another-year-of-bumper-growth-2/

Kementrian Komunikasi dan Informatika, “Atasi Keterbatasan Kapasitas IPv4, Kominfo Dorong Migrasi ke IPv6.” https://www.kominfo.go.id/content/detail/45021/atasi-keterbatasan-kapasitas-ipv4-kominfo-dorong-migrasi-ke-ipv6/0/berita_satker (accessed Sep. 25, 2023).

“Gunakan IPv6 | IDNIC - APJII.” [Online]. Available: https://idnic.net/community/ipv6

“Asosiasi Penyelenggara Jasa Internet Indonesia.” [Online]. Available: https://apjii.or.id/berita/detail/kebutuhan-ip-address-meningkat-apjii-dukung-rencana-penerapan-ipv6_874

P. E. Kristianto and A. T. Putra, “Comparative Analysis of IPv4 and IPv6 OpenVPN Protocol Performance Based on QoS Parameters,” J. Adv. Inf. Syst. Technol., vol. 3, no. 1, 2021, [Online]. Available: https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/index.php/jaist

“Peta Kebocoran Data Global Sepanjang 2022, Termasuk Indonesia.” [Online]. Available: https://dataindonesia.id/digital/detail/peta-kebocoran-data-global-sepanjang-2022-termasuk-indonesia

M. Hickey and J. Arcuri, “Hands on Hacking,” 2020.

D. Yang, H. Wei, Y. Zhu, P. Li, and J. C. Tan, “Virtual Private Cloud Based Power-Dispatching Automation System- Architecture and Application,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Informatics, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 1756–1766, 2019, doi: 10.1109/TII.2018.2849005.

W. O. Zamalia, L. M. F. Aksara, and M. Yamin, “Analisis Perbandingan Performa QoS, PPTP, L2TP, SSTP Dan IPSec pada Jaringan Vpn Menggunakan Mikrotik,” semanTIK, vol. 4, pp. 1–8, 2018.

B. Dwi Satoto, M. Khoironi, J. P. O. Raya Telang BOX, and K. pos, “Pemilihan Prioritas Layanan Qos Dengan Pendekatan Metode Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (Fahp) Dan Topsis.”

M. Rasuanda et al., “Perbandingan Performa VPN Menggunakan PPTP Dan SSTP Over SSL Dengan Metode Quality of Service,” 2020.

M. S. Abjar, “Analisis Perbandingan Protokol Point-to-Point Tunneling Protocol VPN Dengan Protokol Layer Two Tunneling Protocol VPN pada Jaringan IPV6,” 2020.

S. Mackey, I. Mihov, A. Nosenko, F. Vega, and Y. Cheng, “A Performance Comparison of WireGuard and OpenVPN,” in CODASPY 2020 - Proceedings of the 10th ACM Conference on Data and Application Security and Privacy, 2020, pp. 162–164. doi: 10.1145/3374664.3379532.

D. F. Priambodo, Amiruddin, and N. Trianto, “Hardening a Work from Home Network with Wireguard and Suricata,” in 2021 International Conference on Computer Science and Engineering (IC2SE), 2021, vol. 1, pp. 1–4. doi: 10.1109/IC2SE52832.2021.9791983.

Purti, “IPv6 Addresses,” IJRAR- Int. J. Res. Anal. Rev., vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 1–3, 2018.

A. M. Abdulazeez, B. W. Salim, D. Q. Zeebaree, and D. Doghramachi, “Comparison of VPN Protocols at Network Layer Focusing on Wire Guard Protocol,” Int. J. Interact. Mob. Technol., vol. 14, no. 18, pp. 157–177, 2020, doi: 10.3991/ijim.v14i18.16507.

E. Dekker and P. Spaans, “Performance comparison of VPN implementations WireGuard, strongSwan, and OpenVPN in a 1 Gbit/s environment.”

P. A. Wu supervised by Tanja Lange Jacob Appelbaum Jason Donenfeld, “Analysis of the WireGuard protocol,” 2019.

V. Bollapragada, M. Khalid, and S. Wainner, IPSec VPN design : the definitive design and deployment guide for secure virtual private networks. Cisco Press, 2005.

“Apa itu IPSec - IPSec di Amazon Web Services.” [Online]. Available: https://aws.amazon.com/id/what-is/ipsec/

A. Budiman, M. Ficky Duskarnaen, and H. Ajie, “Analisis Quality Of Service (QoS) pada Jaringan Internet SMK Negeri 7 Jakarta,” 2020.

M. Purwahid and J. Triloka, “Analisis Quality of Service (QoS) Jaringan Internet untuk Mendukung Rencana Strategis Infrastruktur Jaringan Komputer di SMK N I Sukadana,” 2019.

F. Rianda, A. Gautama, P. Satwiko, and S. A. Karimah, “Perbandingan Mean Opinion Score (MOS) pada Jaringan VoIP Menggunakan Proportional Integral Controller Enhanced (PIE) dan Droptail.”

I. W. A. P. Ardent Religian Putra. M.Sc., Dwi Fadilla K., ST., MT, “Performansi Layanan Video Conference Pada Jaringan Wide Area Network (WAN) Di Chevron Indonesia Company”.

I. Kadek, S. Satwika, and M. Sukafona, “Analisis Quality of Service Jaringan Virtual Private Network (VPN) di STMIK STIKOM Indonesia,” 2019.

R. FITRIYANTI, L. LINDAWATI, and A. ARYANTI, “Analisis Perbandingan Mean Opinion Score Aplikasi VoIP Facebook Messenger dan Google Hangouts menggunakan Metode E-Model pada Jaringan LTE,” ELKOMIKA J. Tek. Energi Elektr. Tek. Telekomun. Tek. Elektron., vol. 6, no. 3, p. 379, 2018, doi: 10.26760/elkomika.v6i3.379.

S. Narayan, S. Ishrar, A. Kumar, R. Gupta, and Z. Khan, Performance Analysis of 4to6 and 6to4 Transition Mechanisms over Point to Point and IPSec VPN Protocols. 2016.